Journal / COMPARED

Cooling mist vs bracelet vs fan: which menopause cooling product is worth it?

There’s a whole aisle of menopause cooling products now. Here’s what each one is actually good for.

27 SEPT 20267 MIN READBy Love Menopause

Menopause cooling products laid out: LOVE cooling mist, handheld fan, cooling towel, wristband, wipes and ice

Search “menopause cooling products” and you’ll find mists, wristbands, fans, necklaces, wipes, pillows and sheets. Some are great. Some are a fan with a menopause sticker on it. We make a cooling mist, so we’re biased, and we’ll say so. But we also own most of the stuff below, and each one has a job.

One thing first: none of these reduce how often you have hot flashes. The Menopause Society doesn’t recommend cooling techniques as a treatment. They’re for comfort in the moment. If you want fewer hot flashes, that’s a conversation with your doctor.

The quick version

ProductBest forWatch out for
Cooling mistInstant cool on face, neck and chest. Works anywhere, over makeup.Alcohol in some formulas. Patch test if your skin is sensitive.
Cooling braceletHands-free, discreet, all day.Much pricier. Limited research. Has to be worn snug.
Handheld fanCheap, reusable, great on the commute.Only moves air. Noisy ones get looks.
Cooling wipesGym bags and travel.Single use. Some sting.
Cooling beddingNight sweats and hot sleepers.Only helps in bed. Quality varies wildly.

Cooling mists

A cooling mist is a fine spray you put on your face, neck and chest. Some use menthol or a menthol derivative, which triggers the same cold receptors a cool breeze does. Others, like ours, rely on water-based ingredients such as witch hazel and aloe that cool your skin as they evaporate, which works even better with a fan on it.

Good for: the exact moment a hot flash starts. In a meeting, on the train, mid-conversation. A fine mist won’t move your makeup.

What to look for:

  • Alcohol-free. Alcohol evaporates fast but can dry out skin, especially if you spray a lot.
  • Ingredients you’re happy with. Menthol, essential oils and fragrance all feel lovely to some people and irritate others. If your skin is sensitive, patch test first or look for a fragrance-free option.
  • Something for skin. Aloe, glycerin or witch hazel, so you’re not stripping your face ten times a day.
  • A continuous fine mist. Not a spritz that spits.
  • A size you’ll carry. A big bottle that lives in the bathroom is no use in the car. Around 30 to 50 ml fits a bag.
  • Honest claims. A cosmetic mist can make you feel cooler. If it says it “treats” or “cures” hot flashes, that’s a red flag.

Tip: keep it in the fridge door. It comes out colder.

Cooling bracelets

Wearable cooling devices sit on the inside of your wrist and cool the skin there at the press of a button. The best known is the Embr Wave, which uses a small heat pump. Lots of women swear by theirs.

Good for: hands-free, discreet cooling you can use all day.

Watch out for: they cost far more than a mist or a fan. Consumer Reports notes there’s limited published research on using wrist cooling for hot flashes, and that the device needs to be worn snugly to work. Try one with a good return policy.

Handheld and desk fans

Unglamorous, cheap and effective. Moving air over skin makes you feel cooler, and it works even better over skin that’s a little damp. Which is why a fan plus a mist is a very good combination.

Good for: commutes, desks, bedside tables.

Watch out for: battery life, and the noise of the cheaper ones in a quiet office.

Cooling wipes and towels

Pre-soaked wipes and cooling towels are handy after the gym or on holiday. Wipes are single use, and some contain alcohol or menthol strong enough to sting. Test one before you buy a big pack.

Cooling bedding

If nights are the problem, start with the room: cooler temperature, a fan, lighter layers. Then look at breathable sheets like cotton percale, linen or bamboo. Cooling pillows vary a lot. Read reviews from people who sleep hot, not just the product page.

So which should you buy?

Most women we know end up with two things: something cold to spray, and something to move the air. A mist for the moment, a fan for the desk and the bed. Add a bracelet if you want hands-free and don’t mind the price.

And if you’re reaching for any of these every hour, that’s your sign to talk to a doctor.

Where LOVE fits

LOVE is our 45 ml cooling mist: an alcohol-free mist of witch hazel, aloe vera and an essential oil blend, a continuous fine spray, and a size that lives in your handbag or clips onto it. $27. It’s a cosmetic. It makes you feel cooler, fast, and that’s all it claims to do.

Quick answers

What is the best cooling product for hot flashes?

It depends where you need it. A cooling mist is best for instant cold on your face and neck, a fan for your desk or bed, and a cooling bracelet if you want hands-free. None of them reduce how often hot flashes happen.

Do cooling bracelets work for hot flashes?

Many women find them comfortable, but Consumer Reports notes there is limited published research on wrist cooling for hot flashes.

What should I look for in a cooling mist?

Alcohol-free, ingredients that suit your skin, something kind like aloe or witch hazel, a fine continuous spray, a bag-friendly size, and no claims to treat or cure hot flashes.

Sources

  1. Embr Wave 2 review, Consumer Reports
  2. The 2023 nonhormone therapy position statement of The Menopause Society (summary), Breastcancer.org
  3. Hot Flashes, Cleveland Clinic

General information, not medical advice. We make LOVE, a cosmetic cooling mist. It makes you feel cooler and doesn’t treat hot flashes.

More from the Journal